When parents walk into a Virginia custody hearing, one of the biggest questions on their minds is:
“What is the judge going to look at?”
The truth is, Virginia judges don’t pick favorites. They don’t decide based on who has the nicer house or who makes more money. They focus on one thing above all else: the best interests of the child.
But what does that really mean in practice? Let’s break it down.
The Legal Standard: “Best Interests of the Child”
In Virginia, custody decisions are guided by Virginia Code § 20-124.3, which lists 10 key factors judges must consider when deciding what arrangement is best for a child. These factors help judges get a complete picture of the child’s needs, each parent’s ability to meet those needs, and what arrangement will provide stability and growth.
The 10 Custody Factors Judges Consider
Here’s what judges actually look at in Virginia custody cases:
-
The age and physical/mental condition of the child – Younger children often need more hands-on care, while older children may have different needs (school stability, peer relationships, etc.).
-
The age and physical/mental condition of each parent – Judges want to know that a parent is healthy and capable of providing daily care.
-
The relationship between each parent and the child – This includes emotional bonds, involvement in school or activities, and time spent together.
-
The needs of the child – Every child is unique. A child with special medical or educational needs may require a specific type of parenting schedule.
-
The role each parent has played so far and will play in the future – Who has been the primary caregiver? Who handles doctor’s appointments, bedtime routines, homework? Judges weigh past involvement heavily.
-
The willingness of each parent to support the child’s relationship with the other parent – Judges don’t look kindly on a parent who bad-mouths the other or tries to cut them out. Cooperation matters.
- Each parent’s ability to co-parent – Courts want to see parents willing to communicate and make joint decisions when possible.
-
The child’s preference – If a child is mature enough, judges may consider their wishes. There’s no magic age, but judges look at maturity more than a number.
-
Any history of family abuse – This includes physical, emotional, or sexual abuse, or any history of neglect.
-
Any other relevant factors – Judges have flexibility to consider anything important to the child’s wellbeing.
Common Misconceptions About Custody in Virginia
A lot of parents come in with fears that aren’t based in reality. Here are a few myths:
-
❌ “It’s always 50/50 custody.” Not true. While shared custody is common, judges make decisions based on the child’s needs, not a default split.
-
❌ “The child gets to choose where they live at 12 (or 14, or 16).” There’s no set age. Judges may consider a child’s preference if they’re mature enough, but it’s only one factor.
-
❌ “Moms always win custody.” Not anymore. Virginia law doesn’t favor mothers or fathers—only the child’s best interests.
How Parents Can Strengthen Their Case
If you’re preparing for a custody hearing, here are practical steps that show the court you’re child-focused:
-
Keep a journal of your daily involvement (meals, schoolwork, activities).
-
Stay respectful in communication with your co-parent—texts and emails can end up in court.
-
Show willingness to cooperate on schedules and decisions.
-
Focus on your child’s stability and happiness, not on “winning” against the other parent.
Bottom Line
Virginia judges aren’t looking for the “perfect” parent. They’re looking for the arrangement that gives your child the best chance to thrive. If you keep your focus on your child’s wellbeing and demonstrate cooperation, you’ll be presenting your strongest case.
If you’re worried about an upcoming custody case, you don’t have to face it alone. At Collins Family Law, PC, we help parents in Northern Virginia navigate these challenges with clarity and compassion. Call us today at 703-755-7343 to schedule a consultation.